Private credit is undergoing a dynamic transformation, as lenders expand their reach to a broader array of borrowers and diversify the investment vehicles they offer. Simultaneously, a digital revolution is on the horizon, poised to reshape access to private credit for both investors and borrowers in unprecedented ways.
Advocates for tokenization assert that this technology can address key challenges in the private credit landscape. Despite a robust 17% compound annual growth rate over the past five years, a recent Coalition Greenwich survey revealed that many investors still perceive liquidity, efficiency, and transparency as significant barriers to entry. 
Overcoming Barriers Through Tokenization
Liquidity: Tokenization promises to streamline the process of investing in private credit funds and facilitate the trading of shares, thereby widening the investor base and enhancing access to this asset class. This shift could potentially expand the capital available to private credit borrowers.
Efficiency: By utilizing smart contract templates, tokenization can reduce back-office costs, leading to lower transaction fees and management expenses.
Transparency: The integration of a shared ledger for real-time settlements will make the transaction flow of private credit assets more visible, ensuring that data on underlying assets is readily available.
Despite these advantages, a significant portion of wealth and asset managers indicated they would have increased their allocations to private credit investments if not for concerns over liquidity risks and high management fees, according to the Coalition Greenwich survey conducted at the end of 2023. However, 63% of these managers still anticipate raising their allocations to private credit in the coming year.
While tokenization holds the potential to alleviate these barriers, its effectiveness will depend on various factors. For example, while efficiency gains may be achievable, the need for intermediaries—such as broker-dealers and transfer agents—to fulfill specific legal obligations will remain.
Moreover, the promise of enhanced transparency must be carefully balanced against the privacy needs of financial institutions. Portfolio managers often wish to keep their positions confidential to avoid revealing their strategies to competitors, a challenge that public blockchain technologies may pose.
A New Landscape for Investment
Financial institutions and platforms are increasingly exploring the creation of digital tokens representing real-world assets on blockchains, aiming for operational efficiencies and cost savings while improving investor access. Assets like Treasuries, equities, and real estate have already been tokenized, and private credit is beginning to follow suit.
The rise of both private credit and tokenization highlights a growing appetite among market participants for alternative investments and innovative technologies. The private credit market is nearing $1.7 trillion globally, while estimates suggest that only about $500 million is currently represented in tokenized private credit. This segment, however, is expanding rapidly, indicating a significant opportunity for growth.
Moving Beyond Proof of Concept
Financial institutions are investigating whether digital platforms can outperform traditional channels for distributing and managing assets. Initial projects have focused on digital bonds and tokenized money market funds.
Decentralized private credit platforms are also emerging, aiming to enhance credit accessibility in underserved markets. While these platforms may automate operations with smart contracts, they still require trusted intermediaries for policy-setting and custody services, relying on the same legal frameworks that govern traditional lending.
Diverse Tokenization Approaches
Tokenization of private credit can occur in two primary ways: by tokenizing an existing off-chain private credit fund or by leveraging decentralized lending protocols to create on-chain tokenized debt. Hamilton Lane exemplifies the former with its SCOPE fund, which focuses on middle-market corporate loans.
In contrast, decentralized lending platforms encompass a broader range of asset-backed loans, including consumer, auto, fintech, real estate, and carbon projects. The shift in outstanding loans on-chain has been significant since the market decline in 2022, which primarily affected crypto-trading firms.
New growth is increasingly sourced from real-world lending through platforms like Centrifuge, which had $289 million in active loans as of July 2024, focusing on consumer asset-backed securities, real estate bridging loans, and trade finance.
Navigating Challenges to Adoption
While progress is being made, some firms have encountered obstacles that highlight the challenges associated with private credit tokenization. For instance, Percent faced regulatory hurdles, lack of efficiency, and insufficient demand when it attempted to launch its tokenized private debt product.
Furthermore, the quality of credit remains paramount, even in a tokenized environment. Concerns about credit quality have impacted offerings from platforms like Goldfinch, which curtailed its private credit lending due to issues in emerging markets.
Future Prospects for Tokenization
As the landscape of tokenization evolves, several key developments will be crucial for widespread adoption in private credit. These include ensuring credit quality, navigating regulatory frameworks for digital assets, enabling interoperability across various chains, and understanding shifts in investor demand.
Certain jurisdictions have made strides in clarifying legal frameworks for digital securities, which can facilitate investor and originator interest. Additionally, technical interoperability will be essential to support seamless trading and secondary market activity.
Ultimately, the journey toward widespread adoption of tokenization in private credit will be gradual. However, as investor demand builds, we could witness a significant transformation in how private credit operates, merging traditional practices with innovative technologies to create a more accessible and efficient financial landscape.
About the Author:
Ian Scarffe is a serial entrepreneur, investor, key opinion leader and Blockchain consultant with business experience from around the world.
An expert in Startup, Investment, Fintech, Web3, AI, ETF, Digital Assets and Blockchain.
Ian currently consults and advises for a range of multi-million dollar companies.
Ian’s overall mission is to foster a society of economically independent individuals who are engaged citizens, contributing to the improvement of their communities across the world.
Follow Ian Scarffe:
https://uk.linkedin.com/in/ianscarffe
